top of page

Harbour Awarded £7,000 Repair Grant as Stores Condemned After “Wasteful” Request

5 days ago
2 min read

Local councillors have condemned St Andrew’s historic Fisherman’s Stores after rejecting Fife Council’s request for a £230,479 repair grant from the Common Good Fund, prioritising a £6,950 grant for the storm-weathered Harbour instead.


The requested amount was described in a report to the Council’s North East Fife committee as “materially higher” than the building’s £15,000 valuation. The grant, if successful, would have exceeded the £219,805 available in the Fund, leaving no remaining resources for maintenance of other structures and the withdrawal of money from existing investments. The independent councillor Robin Lawson described the request as “a complete and utter waste of money.”


 

Councillor Jane Ann Liston, representing the Liberal Democrats, called it “a bit of a cheek.” Cllr Liston said that the building had become, as far as the Fund was concerned, “no longer an asset [...] a liability, very obviously.”


The status of the building — which is owned and leased by the Council — and its contribution to the Fund had been part of the consideration “given the significant cost relative to market value.” Seven of the nine stores of the B-listed building are let, generating £3,722 annually for the Fund. The condition of the remaining two was too poor to be let.


Upon being asked to grant money for repairs last year, the Committee requested the condition and valuation survey to determine the long-term future of the property and whether to sell, demolish, or commit to a full restoration.


Significant structural defects were revealed, including “timber decay and water damage to the roof timbers over three stores,” “corroded rainwater goods,” and “water ingress affecting an electrical distribution board.” Councillor Lawson, who represents St Andrews, said the disused units were “probably” home to rats and “around 30” pigeons. 


The structure has dirt floors and was uninsulated. A grant of £8,316 had been approved in August 2025 for its maintenance after sustaining weather-related damage. The building is linked to an office displaying the harbourmaster’s contact details, itself adjacent to the public toilets in The Pends. 


In its response to the report, the Committee noted the trade-offs of retaining and repairing the building, which would have preserved any future Fund income but meant high upfront costs and the risk of future liability, and disposal, or demolition, which would have avoided any future drag on the Fund but would have been a “permanent” asset loss. “Significant” conservation constraints, thanks to its status as a listed building, were also flagged as “likely” by Fife Today.


Councillors had been asked to give a “preferred direction of travel” in light of the Committee’s assessment. On 31 October, it was reported that Committee members had agreed to dispose of the building. 


Image by Smilla Spasic


Comments


bottom of page