Ditch or Dance: Welly Ball
Luana van Oranje and John Elwes discuss this year's Welly Ball

Luana:
Well, well, Welly… the reputation certainly precedes the name. Starry-eyed freshers dream of Scotland’s largest black-tie dinner, whilst tweed-clad alumni mull over memories of food fights past. They say to never meet your heroes, and with Welly’s legacy, there were certainly big (Le Chameau) boots to fill.
Welly Ball originated as the monumental finale of the St Andrews Challenge, the University Clay Shooting Club’s annual tournament. Hundreds of keen shots stalked up north from across the country, ready to prove themselves on the shooting grounds or — when their inflated egos inevitably resulted in loss — get revenge with a potato across the dinner floor.
“A lot of carnage,” one visiting alumnus eloquently summarised. Don’t ask whether they emptied the gun or bottle of bubbly first.
For those who hadn’t been boozing since the crack of dawn, no fear. Whilst wrestling your way onto a bus remains the ultimate buzzkill, a true St Andrews classic, the sparkly lights of Falside Mill and welcome drinks a-plenty quickly set the tone. With the live music already playing and multiple bars open for business, the energy was nothing less than electric.
Some attendees posed with the human-sized Le Chameau Boot — this year’s main sponsor — whilst others explored the venue’s less glamorous corners. If there’s one thing the muddy portaloos and larger-than-ever-before medical tent reiterated, it’s that Welly Ball is a marathon, not a sprint. Not even tactfully flat-bottomed footwear can keep you standing once you’re too far gone.
These were not the only operational expansions. Even more so than last year, B-i-g -B-r-o-t-h-e-r security kept strict watch, with an or-Welly-an control over the clay shooting dinner tent and its trays of food. Ironically, it wasn’t here, but rather by the Welly Ball committee’s guests in the Main Barn where potatoes flew. Some might call it hypocrisy. I reserve my thoughts…
But we all know about the food fight already. Just as we all know if you expect the last coach or coat check to go quickly — you are shooting yourself in the (Le Chameau-ed) foot. Yes, maybe we’re all blinded subjects who fail to stand up against these grievances. Or maybe, just maybe, we can support successes in this town rather than complaining and making cheap jokes at one another’s expense. Both Welly Ball’s scale and charitable donation are no small feat; the invite-expecting, nay, demanding socialites of the Social 200 are far too quick to forget that.
Even the greatest critics of St Andrews’ superficial charity events cannot overlook more than £350,000 raised in fourteen years for the Charlie Waller Trust. Welly Ball Co-Director Olivia Dickman explained how the Trust’s mission to “promote awareness and education about mental health for young people” aligns directly with students, for whom “mental health plays a really key role in their day-to-day lives.” This relevancy was echoed by a ball attendee, as he explained that “no one knows how difficult it is until they’ve gone through it.”
He continued, “99% of [the committee] want to make genuine change.” But what is genuine change? Money and longevity of partnership certainly help. However, short-term moral satiation through donation does not absolve us of charitable responsibility for the other 364 days a year.
When considering what responsibility charity events hold beyond their donation, Dickman identified the importance of following up on impact reports. She also highlighted how Welly Ball hosts “talks in freshers’ dorms with the Charlie Waller Trust in hopes of giving [them] greater support systems.” Working for and with charity doesn’t stop with an Instagram post, and Welly Ball recognises that. Bigger is not always better.
Whilst you mull over my two pence, I will hang up my beloved Hunters alongside my cowboy boots and dirndls, highlighting the best of St Andrews events. Bigger in scale, and hopefully donations, than ever before, there is ultimately only one word: C-h-a-m-e-a-u-! Chapeau!
John:
In 1996, sociologist Diane Vaughan coined the term “normalisation of deviance,” arguing that “as the deviant behaviour is repeated without catastrophic results, it becomes the social norm for the organisation.” In other words, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.
Welly Ball has shown few signs of failure. Tickets sell out in seconds, over 2,500 people attend, and dinner ballots remain highly coveted. By every conventional metric, Welly is succeeding. Yet the same familiar complaints seem to resurface year after year: food, buses, prices, and goody bags. The latest rendition was no exception. A cacophony of “f*****g hell,” “f*****g nightmare,” and refund demands resounded from disgruntled attendees.
What went so wrong?
Principally, the buses. After-party guests were left standing in the rain for upwards of an hour and a half for a shuttle to the venue. This miserable and sobering ordeal was made all the more bitter with cloakroom purgatory waiting at the other end. One attendee pointed out a tragicomic contradiction she never expected at Welly — her Wellies were, indeed, wet.
Reasons for the delay were multifaceted: mid-road squatters, shoving matches between guests and security, and doors preemptively shut as collective punishment for the sins of a few all contributed to the chaos. Excessive pat-downs didn’t help, nor did the small matter of nearly 2,000 people attempting to board from a single stop. Stories of panic attacks, fainting, fights, trampled coats, and crushed lungs hardly made for an auspicious start to the evening.
The other (slightly less major) sticking point was the price.
Does a goody bag with some discount codes, some protein balls, an energy patch, and a couple of whisky shooters justify a £90 dinner ticket? Probably not.
Does a “grazing board” with sliced peppers, olives, and a few pre-rolled salami slices (intended for a table of ten) signal the classiness of a black-tie dinner? I don’t think so.
And do a few student DJs, a delayed bus ride, some fairy lights, and £12 gin and tonics warrant a £50 after-party ticket? Almost definitely not.
So why do we keep returning?
Vaughan’s analysis offers a compelling lens. Despite the poor quality of these events’, we’ve come to accept them as the status quo. Because there’s so little going on, any mention of drunken black-tie chaos makes us salivate. Our expectations have lowered to the point where the promise of an event, rather than the quality itself, is enough to secure our attendance.
Now, despite the heavy rain forecast, there were highlights and a general feeling of enjoyment, which sprang forth from the bottle I’d nurtured earlier in the evening. I achieved what the Germans call ‘rausch’ in the interim between dinner and the afterparty while Since Juniper did their usual stint. This golden period was characterised by delights such as: hearing people, finding your friends easily, and breathing freely. If Welly can get it right for an hour, why can't the rest of the event follow?
It would be easy to direct all the blame towards the Welly committee (the temptation is very much there), but the job’s challenges must be acknowledged. Events like Welly take months of planning. This includes liaising between contractors, organising promotional material, working around strict budgets, securing sponsors, and navigating last-minute screw-ups, all while aiming to maximise donations, grappling in tandem with rising costs of everything.
Some would say there isn’t a clear answer. I disagree. Instead of following the same restrictive, outdated blueprint, Welly (and other major events) needs to innovate: multiple departure points for buses, revolutionising the goody bags, better-quality food, multiple cloakrooms, and, most importantly, a feedback survey to break this cycle of normalisation.
Welly survives because tickets still sell out and complaints never leave casual conversation. The first fix comes from us: we need to stop accepting it. Otherwise, expect to be wet, hungry, and queueing again next year.
Photo by Joe Seal




Comments